"Cabaret meets Hedwig and the Angry Inch with a dash of Lady Day..." - Theatre Mania
"Der Gelbe Stern" needs to be seen before it closes... and hopefully in a production somewhere soon thereafter." - Theatre reviews unlimited.
"(Fishman) has the audience in the palm of her hand..." - The BroadwayBlog
"The show's effectiveness is mostly owed to the mesmerizing Fishman" - Stagebuddy